words can’t describe how much I love this.
![never explain a joke. unless it’s this good
aedison:
The Importance of a Single Joke in Community’s “Basic Geneology”.
These two sentences sum up everything Community is. I’ve tried to break down everything this line accomplishes.
It grounds the reality of the show. Prior to this exchange, Chang and Pierce engaged in a fistfight after Pierce attempted to draw a windmill during a game of Pictionaryand ended up obliviously scribbling a swastika on the board instead, offending Chang’s Jewish brother. There’s no denying that that’s a ridiculous scenario, and the fact that it ends with both Change and Pierce bloodied and beaten is absurd.
But our suspension of disbelief isn’t broken, in part because of the deadpan reaction of the policeman[1]. He’s seen this before - so much so that he has an opinion about how to prevent it from happening. When we as viewers see an authority figure treat the goings-on as realistic, we further invest in the show’s overall realism.
It illustrates that the show doesn’t indulge in easy caricatures. Typically, if you see an officer of the law in sitcom, he or she is either going to be dumb and incompetent or mean and unreasonable. In Community, we instead get a perfectly calm, logical cop accepts the problems he encounters and deals with them efficiently and kindly, even offering gentle -but clever- advice for the future. Although he’s in the episode for less than thirty seconds, this guy is already a fleshed-out human being. I know this dude.
It provides one of the biggest laughs of the episode, despite essentially repeating a joke we’ve already seen. The seed of the joke -the recontextualization of windmill as swastika- has, by now in the episode, already been planted, watered, and allowed to bloom into a flower. Most sitcoms would have had the fight be the endpoint of the joke, and any dealings with the aftermath quickly dealt with to allow the plot to progress.
In Community, though, the joke is allowed to live on past that endpoint, and the writers are clever enough to re-word the gag in a way that not only doesn’t bore us, but makes us laugh out loud. “One character misinterprets a windmill as a swastika” becomes “one character explains that windmills are commonly misinterpreted as swastikas” and it seems both entirely fresh and like a perfect button to the first iteration of the joke. That’s hard to do.
It gives us a glimpse of the larger world of the show, while not taking us out of the inner world we’re paying attention to. With this simple line, the writers convey that this classic comedy mis-understanding isn’t unique to Greendale Community College. The fact that the cop has an opinion at all illustrates, as mentioned above, that these kind of incidents happen often in the surrounding world. We learn that the rest of the Community universe is just as crazy as the college itself, that Greendale is the rule, not the exception.
The fact that this one line is so efficient, does so much heavy-lifting, is astounding. And it’s hardly an anomaly - most Community lines are crammed with levels of humor and insights into the world of the show. Community is often called one of the smartest shows on television, and it’s not just because the dialogue is fast-paced and pop-culture laden or the high-concept episodes are so striking and original. It’s because the people behind the show care so much about every single word that comes out of these characters’s mouths that they make each one of those words count.
Much credit, of course, should go to Craig Cackowski, who played the officer in question, and Ken Whittingham, who directed the episode. The standard sitcom reading of “…until Pictionary bans the word ‘windmill’” would be wacky and over-the-top, and these guys clearly made an active choice to go the other way. ↩](http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m4hdiyyqAu1qzpcyco1_1280.jpg)
never explain a joke. unless it’s this good
The Importance of a Single Joke in Community’s “Basic Geneology”.
These two sentences sum up everything Community is. I’ve tried to break down everything this line accomplishes.
- It grounds the reality of the show. Prior to this exchange, Chang and Pierce engaged in a fistfight after Pierce attempted to draw a windmill during a game of Pictionaryand ended up obliviously scribbling a swastika on the board instead, offending Chang’s Jewish brother. There’s no denying that that’s a ridiculous scenario, and the fact that it ends with both Change and Pierce bloodied and beaten is absurd.
But our suspension of disbelief isn’t broken, in part because of the deadpan reaction of the policeman[1]. He’s seen this before - so much so that he has an opinion about how to prevent it from happening. When we as viewers see an authority figure treat the goings-on as realistic, we further invest in the show’s overall realism.
It illustrates that the show doesn’t indulge in easy caricatures. Typically, if you see an officer of the law in sitcom, he or she is either going to be dumb and incompetent or mean and unreasonable. In Community, we instead get a perfectly calm, logical cop accepts the problems he encounters and deals with them efficiently and kindly, even offering gentle -but clever- advice for the future. Although he’s in the episode for less than thirty seconds, this guy is already a fleshed-out human being. I know this dude.
It provides one of the biggest laughs of the episode, despite essentially repeating a joke we’ve already seen. The seed of the joke -the recontextualization of windmill as swastika- has, by now in the episode, already been planted, watered, and allowed to bloom into a flower. Most sitcoms would have had the fight be the endpoint of the joke, and any dealings with the aftermath quickly dealt with to allow the plot to progress.
In Community, though, the joke is allowed to live on past that endpoint, and the writers are clever enough to re-word the gag in a way that not only doesn’t bore us, but makes us laugh out loud. “One character misinterprets a windmill as a swastika” becomes “one character explains that windmills are commonly misinterpreted as swastikas” and it seems both entirely fresh and like a perfect button to the first iteration of the joke. That’s hard to do.
- It gives us a glimpse of the larger world of the show, while not taking us out of the inner world we’re paying attention to. With this simple line, the writers convey that this classic comedy mis-understanding isn’t unique to Greendale Community College. The fact that the cop has an opinion at all illustrates, as mentioned above, that these kind of incidents happen often in the surrounding world. We learn that the rest of the Community universe is just as crazy as the college itself, that Greendale is the rule, not the exception.
The fact that this one line is so efficient, does so much heavy-lifting, is astounding. And it’s hardly an anomaly - most Community lines are crammed with levels of humor and insights into the world of the show. Community is often called one of the smartest shows on television, and it’s not just because the dialogue is fast-paced and pop-culture laden or the high-concept episodes are so striking and original. It’s because the people behind the show care so much about every single word that comes out of these characters’s mouths that they make each one of those words count.
Much credit, of course, should go to Craig Cackowski, who played the officer in question, and Ken Whittingham, who directed the episode. The standard sitcom reading of “…until Pictionary bans the word ‘windmill’” would be wacky and over-the-top, and these guys clearly made an active choice to go the other way. ↩
![That is the coolest sentence I have ever heard somebody talk
The Best Of #andy DwyerWith the Parks and Recreation season finale in store for us this Thursday and the triumphant return of Burt Macklin last Thursday, I think it’s high time we finally dedicate […]
Source: Uproxx](http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m3olv5swXG1qa9muto1_400.gif)
That is the coolest sentence I have ever heard somebody talk
The Best Of #andy Dwyer
With the Parks and Recreation season finale in store for us this Thursday and the triumphant return of Burt Macklin last Thursday, I think it’s high time we finally dedicate […]
Source: Uproxx
![Nick Offerman Shares His 10 Secrets To Life At Tulane#4 – Eat red meat. #5 – Get a hobby. “Hobby is an unfortunate word, like underpants, Mitt, and Romney, for something that can have such a profound impact on […]Source: Uproxx](http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m3lrw81E5P1qa9muto1_500.jpg)
Nick Offerman Shares His 10 Secrets To Life At Tulane
#4 – Eat red meat. #5 – Get a hobby. “Hobby is an unfortunate word, like underpants, Mitt, and Romney, for something that can have such a profound impact on […]
#4 – Eat red meat. #5 – Get a hobby. “Hobby is an unfortunate word, like underpants, Mitt, and Romney, for something that can have such a profound impact on […]
Source: Uproxx
![Louis C.k’s New, New Testament: 20 Commandments To Live ByI was re-watching a Louis C.K. stand-up special on Netflix this weekend (because there’s nothing else to watch on Netflix, but that’s another story on another site) and as I […]
Source: WarmingGlow](http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m2y6m8QZze1qa9muto1_500.jpg)
Louis C.k’s New, New Testament: 20 Commandments To Live By
I was re-watching a Louis C.K. stand-up special on Netflix this weekend (because there’s nothing else to watch on Netflix, but that’s another story on another site) and as I […]
Source: WarmingGlow
